As the girls approach their second birthdays, I’ve been thinking more and more about their personalities – in particular their differences and similarities. I’ve always tried to avoid overtly pigeonholing them (I’m sure I probably do subconsciously) in terms of ‘Oh G does this and R does that’ but as their carers’ at nursery have said, while they may look identical, their personalities are quite different.
R really likes her gadgets and toys and is a deep thinker with a real mischievous streak and an evil cackle. She styles herself as the ringleader and consequently can be a bit of a bully at times. She’s also extremely bossy (can't think where she gets that from!) and dh is normally the target of her pointing and directing. R is quieter than her sister, unless really annoyed but is very determined and knows her own mind. Woe betide anyone that pushes her to her (very set) limits! She's very poised and graceful (the normal accidents that befall the average toddler seem to bypass her) and always seems to think about ten steps ahead.
G is very kind - more of a people-person than R. She's very sensitive to the feelings of others and is extremely affectionate, with lots of cuddles and kisses for everyone. She can be quite clingy and whingy at times and is prone to exaggeration (one day we will invest in a fainting couch for her swooning moments) and loud tantrums. She loves singing, dancing and chatting and is generally the louder of the two. She's very accident-prone (another trait she shares with me) and always has bruises and cuts. She tends to launch herself at things and hopes for the best - not always with good results!
They have things in common as well though: they adore all animals; they love doing puzzles and reading. They seem to bounce off each other - e.g. G will sing and R will act as her very appreciative audience, clapping and shouting ‘MORE MORE!’ at the end of every song. When one of them is scared of something the other one will lead them by the hand and help them out. G knows when R is in a really bad mood and stays out of her way, or tries to cheer her up with a favourite toy. When G has one of her wobblers, R acts like the older sister with a mildly indulgent ‘Oh dear, look at the toddler being silly’ expression on her face.
It blows my tiny mind that two beings that look so ridiculously similar can approach life in such different ways. How can that possibly work? To try and understand it, I read back over some early blog entries to try and work out whether R and G were born with the personalities they have, or whether we have, to a greater or lesser degree, ‘imposed’ some elements of their personalities on them – nurture rather than nature.
The following extracts are quite enlightening:
27th February 2008 (10 weeks old)
“They are also developing different personalities. G is shaping up to be a little diva, as she kicks off about anything and everything and is a total daddies girl who wants to be cuddled all the time. She loves nothing more than lying on someone’s chest, preferably that of a large male. R is more laid-back and considered and only gets angry if she thinks she is being denied milk. She hates being a baby and wants to be with adults all the time. It will be fascinating to see how they grow and change over time.”
15th March 2008 (3 months old)
“(G) has just come out of a ‘crusty’ phase... made worse by the fact that R looks completely immaculate and G looked like the poor relation in comparison... Someone told me that there are ‘Toy babies’ and ‘People babies’. G is definitely a people baby.... She is much chattier than R. The girls are noticing each other more and more now and G will beam at R and chat away for ages. R looks confused, smiles rather uncertainly occasionally and just stares at this noisy little creature.... I have a theory that while R is more like a singleton baby, G is more like one half of a twin pairing. When they are playing, G looks over at R to see what she is doing. R does her own thing”.
“(R) also has what is known by our friends and family as ‘The Ruthie stare’, where she is so completely and utterly irritated that she fixes us with a cold stare for a few seconds, then looks away and refuses to look back. If she could say ‘WhatEVER’ or ‘Bovvered?’, she would. When she eventually gets what she wants (i.e. milk) we get a smug grin accompanied with a ‘If you listened to me I wouldn’t have to resort to such extreme measures’ look.... R will play with a toy for longer than G... I suspect that R is frustrated with being able to do so little physically... If she’s like this at 3 months, I dread to think what the 13 year old R will be like!”
Scary. We didn’t ‘decide’ to make them how they are. I don’t think we have imposed personality traits on them. They were already there when the girls were born. Nature or nurture? I say nature.
